Archive for the ‘Lawrence Tynes’ Category

New York Giants Pre Preseason Roster Prediction

August 9th, 2010 at 5:49 PM
By SimonGC

Here we go again, folks. It’s that time of year. A few things have changed since the last roster prediction. Injuries, recoveries and performances have shifted the balance of certain units, and therefore the roster overall. My Prediction:

QB- Eli Manning, Jim Sorgi

The Giants have carried two QB’s the last couple of years, and Rhett Bomar will really have to impress in the preseason to avoid the waiver gauntlet, and ultimately the practice squad.

FB- Madison Hedgecock

Hedgecock didn’t seem to be in much trouble coming into camp, but a recent bit about Jerome Johnson’s good camp and Maddy’s handful of drops could be noteworthy. Hedgecock is a trusted veteran, but is coming off a down season due to an injured shoulder that required surgery. Would the Giants be tempted make a mini-youth movement here, saving about $600,000 this year? I’m not ready to go that far yet.

RB- Ahmad Bradshaw, Brandon Jacobs, Andre Brown, DJ Ware

For most of this offseason I’ve been suggesting the Giants carry 5 RB’s, but with Bradshaw, Jacobs and Brown looking healthy that extra insurance policy might not be necessary. Gartrell Johnson’s sluggish start to camp hasn’t helped his cause. Look for Brown to get some situational work out of the backfield if he can prove a reliable pass blocker, and DJ Ware to return kickoffs and perhaps spell the top two guys occasionally.

TE- Kevin Boss, Travis Beckum, Bear Pascoe

This unit seems a little thin, with Boss coming off the ankle surgery (now nursing a hammy) and Beckum’s noted lack of blocking skills (and a hammy, too)! Pascoe has had an up and down camp, and it’s possible Scott Chandler could steal that roster spot or even come in as the 4th guy. Hey, you can’t be stacked everywhere.

WR- Hakeem Nicks, Steve Smith, Mario Manningham, Derek HaganSinorice MossRamses Barden

Not much to say here, although many Giants fans will be lamenting Moss’ continued presence on the roster. Tim Brown’s opened some eyes recently in camp, but the Sinorice Moss carbon copy will probably need to wrestle the kickoff return job from DJ Ware to either be carried as the 7th guy or bump someone (Moss?) off the roster.

OL- David Diehl, Rich Seubert, Shaun O’Hara, Chris Snee, Kareem McKenzie, William Beatty, Guy Whimper, Mitch Petrus, Adam Koets

We can argue all day about who lines up where, but that’s pretty much what the roster is going to look like. Kevin Boothe’s placement on the PUP due to a pectoral injury cleared the depth situation up a little bit, but you have to wonder if there is room for him when he’s ready to come back. Assuming everyone is healthy, it probably comes down to who the Giants like better: Boothe or Whimper.

CB- Corey Webster, Terrell Thomas, Aaron Ross, Bruce Johnson, D.J. Johnson

Again, not a lot of surprises here. If Ross is going to be the nickel back, he’s certainly got my vote to return punts. D.J. Johnson’s only up there because he was on the roster last year, and it’s possible that Seth Williams or Courtney Brown could take hold of that spot. With a WR group that underwhelms (outside of Hagan) on special teams, contributions in that department are going to go a long way in winning that CB last spot.

S- Antrel Rolle, Kenny Phillips, Deon Grant, Michael Johnson

This is another unit I thought might carry five guys, but with Chad Jones going down early that doesn’t look likely. This unit might shake out a few different ways with Phillips’ health, and Grant and Johnson presumably battling for depth chart dominance over one another, but these should be the four guys. Sha’Reff Rashad has been hanging around since last year, but he’s probably ticketed for the practice squad again. If Michael Johnson does get buried on the depth chart, he’s a good candidate to win a job as a punt gunner opposite Hagan.

LB- Michael Boley, Keith Bulluck, Clint Sintim, Jonathon Goff, Chase Blackburn, Bryan Kehl, Phillip Dillard

This is a crowded group, but for starters I’d think Coughlin would be fed up with Gerris Wilkinson by now, and its doubtful he even gets the chance to win over Perry Fewell. Adrian Tracy, the sixth-round DE convert probably could use a year on the practice squad to get used to a new position. If Goff straight up wins the MLB job from Bulluck, do the Giants even keep Bulluck around? Will Chase Blackburn successfully force the coaching staff to keep him around (again)? Are the Giants ready give up on Kehl? If Mathias Kiwanuka is going to get reps at linebacker, it’s quite likely that the answer to one of these questions will be bad news for somebody on the above list, with the roster spot going perhaps to a defensive back, a tight end or Rhett Bomar.

DE- Justin Tuck, Mathias Kiwanuka, Osi Umenyiora, Jason Pierre-Paul, Dave Tollefson

DT- Chris Canty, Barry Cofield, Linval Joseph, Jay Alford

Ok, let’s do these two units together, since the decision really comes down to keeping Tollefson or Rocky Bernard. Tollefson sticks because the Giants have more DE’s that can swing inside than vice-versa, and he’s also been the other guy (behind Kiwanuka) taking reps at LB. The fact that he’s on both punt and kick coverage teams and costs a heck of a lot less doesn’t hurt either. Cutting Bernard and allowing Kiwanuka to stand up bodes well for the Giants defensive line, as it indicates the coaches are comfortable with the early progress made by Joseph and Pierre-Paul. Can’t stress enough that a return to form for the D-line is the Giants most pressing issue.

K- Lawrence Tynes

Ugh.

P- Matt Dodge

After a rocky start to training camp, Dodge has reportedly found a groove and shown off the monstrous leg power he was reputed to have. His strong leg should allow him to do a decent job early, but there hasn’t been much of an effort to kick directionally. Plus, the kid’s apparently “built like a linebacker,” so we should all be excited to see the first time he lays someone out.

LS- Zak DeOssie

Not listed with the linebackers, as Tynes mentioned he wouldn’t really be working with them this season. A bad moment in your career, but at least you still have a job! I suppose his presence down here might incline the Giants slightly to carry one less linebacker. Slightly.

Giants Training Camp Thoughts 8/6

August 6th, 2010 at 8:54 AM
By Rich O'Callaghan

So we the Giants have been in Albany since last Sunday and some players have already stood out at training camp. Here are some of my observations and thoughts based on reports coming out of Albany this week: 

  • First, and most importantly, the injury to second year receiver Hakeem Nicks’ right knee was not serious. Giants fans worldwide held their breath, but after being examined by a doctor and receiving two MRIs on his knee, Nicks got the results. Nothing. Not even a hyperextension. Nicks returned to practice last night in full pads and did not miss a beat, making several great catches. Breathe easy Giants fans.
  • Chris Canty looks like a monster this year, and is 100% healthy. The defensive tackle looked lean last season, after coming to the Giants as a free agent from Dallas, where he played defensive end. It looks like Canty took his off season workouts very seriously, because the first thing many reporters on site noted was how much bigger he looked, more like a true defensive tackle than an end. Canty added good mass too, looking ripped at his additional weight. His leg is also fully healed as he consistently has gotten pressure from the inside he has and used his long arms to swat down several passes so far in camp. This is all great news, expect big things from him in 2010.
  • The other member of the Giants defense who has noticeably added bulk and size this off season is weakside linebacker Michael Boley, who has done so to help him in run support. Boley looks much stronger, but has not lost any of his quickness, and has been flying around practice making plays all over the field. He has also made some plays in pass coverage, and has had at least one interception, though it may have been more. Boley was the Giants best linebacker in 2009, but it was a pretty weak group, and I think he will be even better this season.
  • Inside linebacker Jonathan Goff is drawing a lot of praise from practice observers. He has been running with the first team defense and has been making a lot of plays, including chasing down shifty tailback Ahmad Bradshaw in the backfield for a five-yard loss. When the Giants signed linebacker Keith Bulluck, it was assumed that he would be handed the starting job inside, but he has been very limited in practice so far, playing with the second team as he rehabs his knee. Meanwhile, Goff is doing all of the right things, and proving he will not give up the starting job without a fight.
  • The Giants top four cornerbacks have all looked fantastic so far in preseason, Corey Webster made the highlight play of camp so far, with a one handed interception of an Eli Manning pass. Terrell Thomas has been solid, intercepting some passes and knocking some balls down. Aaron Ross is fully healthy and in the best shape of his life, making several very athletic plays, including an interception at the peak of his vertical jump which drew a cheer from the crowd. Bruce Johnson’s improvement has wowed the coaching staff, and he has been all over the field this week, he no longer looks lost in the NFL, but like he belongs. New Giants defensive coordinator Perry Fewell was a defensive backs coach before becoming a coordinator, and he is known for improving secondary play wherever he goes, so hopefully the play of the corners on the field is proof of Fewell’s positive impact on the defense.
  • Speaking of Fewell, his enthusiasm and energy are evident on the practice field, and he can be easily heard shouting instructions or criticism at players from the stands. The team seems to like him and his style is a welcome change after the firing of the statuesque Bill Sheridan’s coaching style (or lack thereof).
  • Rookie defensive linemen Jason-Pierre Paul and Linval Joseph have both impressed so far in Albany, and both have been rotating in with the first team defense. There is no denying JPP’s athleticism, and he has blown by several offensive linemen, and had what would have been a sack (if there was contact on the QB) on a stunt against the first team offensive line. He also destroyed Bear Pascoe, the Giants best run blocking tight end, to make a stuff in the backfield. He still has a lot to learn about the game, but he is a physical freak who can do one thing well right off the bat, get to the quarterback. Linval Joseph is a mountain of a man, who has long arms and is extremely strong, and he has impressed with his relentlessness on the field. Joseph needs some work on his conditioning and technique, but he could be part of the rotation at defensive tackle right away. I think JPP will come into games against tired offensive lines early on in his career in passing situations and give opponents fits. We should see both of these players on the field earlier than I once thought, possibly as soon as week one.
  • The rest of the defensive line has also been phenomenal in training camp, especially ends Justin Tuck, Osi Umenyiora and Mathais Kiwanuka. In fact they have destroyed the Giants offensive line, and each player would had have several sacks last night if this was live on the quarterback. Kiwanuka picked up a fumble on a low snap to Eli and ran it back for a score. The Giants even showed the terrifying lineup of Tuck, Osi, Kiwi and JPP during the two minute drill. I would like to predict that Dave Tollefson makes this team, the coaching staff loves him and he has been rotating in regularly at end.  He has made an impact, at one point beating William Beatty on back to back plays for a sack and a stuff on a run five yards in the backfield. The only concerning thing about the defensive line has the health of Jay Alford’s surgically repaired knee, where he is apparently experiencing pain.       
  • The Giants running backs are all healthy and have taken to training camp without physical limitations. Brandon Jacobs (knee) seems to be in 2008 form and says his knee is 100% healthy. Ahmad Bradshaw (ankles, foot) looks as fast and quick as ever and is having no problem cutting, really looking impressive at practice last night. Andre Brown (Achilles) is the biggest surprise of all, showing no effects of the injury that cost him his rookie season and was considered career-threatening. Brown has looked great catching the ball out of the backfield and could bring another dimension to the Giants offense as a receiver and third-down back.
  • Center Shaun O’Hara’s ankle injury (not serious) has allowed the Giants staff to take an extensive look at the offensive line I have been hoping the team will switch to since the end of last season. With O’Hara temporarily sidelined, Rich Seubert is playing center with David Diehl playing left guard and William Beatty lining up at left tackle. When O’Hara returns, I hope Seubert becomes the backup at center/guard, with Diehl sticking at left guard and Beatty at left tackle, but I could see Tom Coughlin going back to the line that struggled in 2009 and keeping Beatty on the bench for another year. The bad news is, although rookie guard Mitch Petrus and reserve center Adam Koets have shown flashes and played well, the offensive line is getting manhandled by the Giants defensive front in practice. 
  • Ramses Barden continues to impress the coaching staff, making highlight catches regularly, using his long arms to reach over defensive backs for receptions. He is running better routes and looks much more adjusted to the pro game than he did last season. With the season ending injury to Domenik Hixon, Barden should be the Giants fourth wide receiver and a consistent jump ball threat in the red zone in 2010.
  • The team is clearly expecting a lot out of rookie punter Matt Dodge, who looked shaky early on punting the ball, but has since recovered to nail some booming punts. Dodge is also the holder on field goal attempts, and has done a great job handling a few low snaps and getting them down for kicker Lawrence Tynes, who is perfect so far on field goals. Nice start for the specialists. 
  • The entire Giants team reported in shape and Coughlin said everyone made weight. This may or may not be related to Fred Robbins now being a member of the Rams. Gartrell Johnson struggled during conditioning drills, but continues to run hard on every handoff during practice.
  • One of the offensive stars of camp is wide receiver Derek Hagan, who has no speed, but catches every ball thrown anywhere near him. Sinorice Moss has also made some outstanding plays in camp. I hope that the play of these two does not keep Ramses Barden on the sidelines for another year.  
  • We have a battle on our hands, as the Giants third string quarterback Rhett Bomar is completely outplaying the backup quarterback Jim Sorgi. According to the coaching staff, the more experienced Sorgi’s backup job is not in jeopardy, but Bomar may be doing enough to stick on the active roster. Remember, Bomar is extremely gifted, he would have been a first round draft pick if he was not thrown out of Oklahoma and forced to finish his career at Sam Houston State. I just question weather the Giants carry three quarterbacks, it has not been their style as of late. 
  • Now time for a few tough observations – I keep hearing that Clint Sintim is playing well on the strong side and no longer being fooled by misdirection, but I am not hearing his name on practice reports. Where has he been? It sounds like rookie linebacker Adrian Tracy is really struggling with the transition from college defensive end to pro linebacker. He will likely be on the practice squad this season. Travis Beckum needs to get healthy fast, he has missed the last few practices with tightness in his hamstring, and he cannot impress the coaching staff from the bench. Jay Alford is extremely frustrated with the setback to his knee, likely because he knows his spot in the rotation is in jeopardy, as he is in a direct battle with Linval Joseph and Rocky Bernard, who have impressed, for playing time. When will Kenny Phillips actually practice? The word is sometime late next week at the earliest. Where has rookie linebacker Phillip Dillard been? I have not heard his name once. Are the Giants really going to enter the 2010 season with reserve tailback D.J. Ware as the primary return man? If I am Jerry Reese, I am spending most of my time looking for a kick returner, because Ware deep scares nobody. I think we can all agree that he will not be the next Dante Hall.
  • Finally, the addition of Antrel Rolle has brought swagger back to the Giants secondary, as he has been a vocal leader on the field from the start of camp. Rolle ended practice yesterday with a interception off of Eli Manning (who would have been sacked in reality) that he high stepped all the way back for a touchdown, and ended with an end zone dance. The coaching staff has raved about new safety additions Rolle and Deon Grant (who sat out last night due to a groin injury) as leaders and talented players. I could not be happier to have the two of them helping the back end of the defense in 2010. 

Giants Camp: What to Watch

July 30th, 2010 at 10:21 AM
By Rich O'Callaghan

Giants training camp kicks off on Sunday, and I could not be more excited. Here are some things I will be keeping an eye on throughout the preseason.

  • How Does Linebacker Depth Pan Out? We know that the newly signed Keith Bulluck is the favorite to win the Giants middle linebacker job, and Clint Sintim and Michael Boley are will be starting on the outside. The Giants have a lot of young depth behind these players, many who will have to be cut by the end of preseason. You have Jonathan Goff, the favotite to start at MLB before the Bulluck addition and Gerris Wilkinson, a great special teamer (when healthy) who could back up the middle and weakside. There are experienced depth players, who are favorites of the coaching staff such and Chase Blackburn and Bryan Kehl and young players like rookies Adrian Tracy and Phillip Dillard, along with Kenny Ingram, who was on the practice squad last season. The linebackers will be an interesting group to keep an eye on this preseason, as a few longtime Giants will likely be released in favor of youthful depth. When Bulluck (knee) is sitting out one practice a day, keep an eye on who is taking first team reps, if it is Dillard then Goff is on the roster bubble.
  • Who is the Fifth Cornerback? The Giants top four corners are set, with Corey Webster, Terrell Thomas, Aaron Ross and Bruce Johnson. An injury to any of these players would really make this unit thin, and we all know Ross has had trouble staying healthy in the past, so the fifth cornerback could play a big role in 2010. The likeliest candidates are D.J. Johnson, Courtney Brown and undrafted free agent Seth Williams. The Giants would be crazy to carry only four cornerbacks, so one of these three will make the final roster this season.
  • Offensive Line Changes? Will Tom Coughlin and his coaching staff make changes to the offensive line, or stick with an experienced unit that struggled in 2010? Second year tackle William Beatty played very well in limited action last season, and I have been calling for him to start on the left side, sliding Dave Diehl to left guard and making Rich Seubert a valuable reserve at center or guard. The Giants have not committed to this move, though they have admitted that it is possible. I think that starting Beatty makes the unit stronger, but have my doubts that the Giants staff makes such a radical move and changes a unit that they have been comfortable with in the past.
  • Who Will Return Kicks/Punts? The loss of Domenik Hixon hurt the Giants badly in this department. Some names have been floated around (Antrel Rolle, Ahmad Bradshaw, Aaron Ross, Mario Manningham) but these players are far too valuable in other facets of the game to risk in the return game. Sinorice Moss will get a look in the return game, but he has been unable to win the job in the past. Other unknowns like D.J. Ware and Tim Brown will also have the opportunity to compete, but I cannot help but thinking that the player who wins this job is not on the current roster.  I am sure Jerry Reese will be closely monitoring who is released during final cuts around the league, because if someone with return skills is out there, the Giants sure could use them.
  • Who is the Fourth Receiver? The Giants top three receivers are set in stone with the talented young core of Steve Smith, Hakeem Nicks and Mario Manningham leading the way.  Injured return man Domenik Hixon would have been the favorite in the fourth receiver role, but his knee injury opened up a serious competition for that spot. The consensus amongst fans seems to be Ramses Barden should have every opportunity to win this job, but while he has made some legendary catches in practice, we have yet to see him do it on Sundays. Playing Barden more could have some major advantages, because none of the other Giants receivers have his size, and he could become a major threat in the red zone. Other players who will be competing for this spot include veterans Sinorice Moss and Derek Hagan, and second year Tight End/H-Back/Slot Travis Beckum will also see reps.
  • How Healthy are the Walking Wounded? The Giants had to have been the most banged up team in the NFL last season.  How healthy are Kenny Phillips (knee), Justin Tuck (shoulder), Osi Umenyiora (hip, knee), Hakeem Nicks (toe), Mario Manningham (shoulder), Kevin Boss (ankle), Chris Canty (calf, hamstring), Barry Cofield (knee), Rocky Bernard (shoulder), Rich Seubert (shoulder) , Kareem McKenzie (knee, back), Shaun O’Hara (knee), Ahmad Bradshaw (foot, ankles), Brandon Jacobs (knee), Jay Alford (knee), Corey Webster (knee), Aaron Ross (hamstrings), Michael Boley (hamstrings), Andre Brown (Achillies), Keith Bulluck (knee)? Are they all  going to be ready to go for the 2010 season kickoff versus a Panthers team that ran the ball down their throats just a few months ago?
  • NOTES: It was announced that Super Bowl legend David Tyree and former first round pick and longtime possession receiver Ike Hilliard have both signed one day contracts to retire as Giants. Hilliard actually had a productive 12-year career (8 years with the Giants) and Tyree was a career special teamer (made the Pro Bowl in 2005) who played five of his six years with the Giants, and will always be remembered for his miracle catch in the Super Bowl XLII victory over the heavily favored Patriots. Both guys are class acts and I am proud to see them retire as Giants.
  • The Giants claimed defensive end/linebacker Alex Hall off waivers from the hated Philadelphia Eagles. Hall (6′2 250lbs) had his most success playing outside linebacker in the Browns 3-4 defense with 28 tackles and 3.0 sacks in 2008, but was traded to the Eagles as part of the Sheldon Brown deal, where he struggled as a traditional defensive end. I would put Hall’s chances of making the Giants at slim, and think he will eventually catch on with another defensive 3-4 team (the Bills need all the help they can get). Prove me wrong Alex, prove me wrong.
  • The Giants waived rookie safety Chad Jones, who was tragically injured in a car accident, and nearly lost his leg. This move had to be made, as once Jones clears waivers, he will be placed on the non-football injury list and will no longer take up a roster spot. The Giants are also no longer obligated to pay Jones a base salary, but will “take care of him in some form or fashion.” The team has already paid him a $825,000 signing bonus.
  • First round pick Jason Pierre-Paul and second round pick Linval Joseph are both still unsigned, with the start of training camp looming on Sunday, but I expect both players to be signed and report on time. I’ll update the post if either one inks a deal.

Giant Weakness: Special Teams

July 20th, 2010 at 8:49 AM
By Rich O'Callaghan

I am confident that the New York Giants have improved offensively and defensively over the off-season due to additions and the improved health of both units. However, the team still has one major weakness that they will have to overcome to become elite once again in 2010. Of course I am talking about special teams. Why do I think the Giants special teams will struggle?

  • The Retirement of Jeff Feagles - After an illustrious 22 year career, Giants punter Jeff Feagles retired on April 30th at the age of 44. Feagles no longer had a big leg, but was still a fantastic directional punter for the Giants, who often pinned opponents deep in their own territory. Feagles holds records for: Most Consecutive Games Played (352), Most Career Punts (1,713), Most Punts Inside the 20 (497) and Most Punting Yards Career (71,211). His retirement was not unexpected, but his consistency will be greatly missed in 2010.
  • Rookie Punter: Matt Dodge - With the 221st pick of the 2010 NFL Draft, the Giants drafted punter Matt Dodge from East Carolina. Dodge is known for his big leg, and he can easily boot the ball over 50-yards. He does have to improve on his accuracy, and has had problems angling his punts in the past, which the Giants like to do strategically to keep the ball away from dangerous divisional return men like DeSean Jackson (Eagles) and Felix Jones (Cowboys). The Giants need Dodge to step up right away and fill the void left by Feagles’ retirement. I am cautiously optimistic that he is up to the task, but he is an unknown entering the 2010 season. I am also hoping that Dodge will be able to kick the ball off for the Giants, because Lawrence Tynes was awful on kickoffs in 2009, and the Giants attempt to sign kickoff specialist Rhys Lloyd fell through this off season, as he opted to sign with the Minnesota Vikings.
  • Lawrence Tynes’ Struggles - One of the biggest frustrations Giants fans have had over the past few seasons has been the up and down play of place kicker Lawrence Tynes. For example, Tynes biggest kick as a Giant came when he hit the game-winning 47-yard field goal in overtime at frigid Green Bay to win the 2007-2008 NFC Championship for the Giants en route to a Super Bowl victory. Of course, Tynes missed two potentially game winning field goals earlier in this same game. His inconsistency is maddening, and I often find it hard to watch as Tynes sets for a field goal attempt, even kicks that should be automatic. I feel that Tynes usually kicks the ball well in high pressure situations, but seems to miss a lot of easy field goals early in games. He is also terrible at kicking the ball off, and opponents usually have great field position when beginning drives against the Giants. I am hoping that rookie punter Matt Dodge can use his big leg and relieve Tynes of this duty, making him strictly a place kicker. I would love to see the Giants bring in a more consistent kicker to battle Tynes, as they have in the past, but so far Tynes had beaten all challengers for the job. I am shocked by how few reliable kickers are currently playing in the NFL. If you want your kid to have a decent shot at the league, have them practice kicking.
  • Domenik Hixon’s Knee Injury - Earlier this off season at OTAs, receiver Domenik Hixon suffered a torn ACL and was lost for the 2010 season. He was subsequently waived by the organization and was placed on the injured reserve upon clearing waivers on July 17th. Hixon was a speedy receiver who was a threat to beat a defense deep, but his real value came on special teams, where he was one of the best return men in the league. In 2009, Hixon averaged a respectable 22.6 yards per kickoff return and was second in the league in punt return average (behind Philly’s DeSean Jackson) with a 15.1 yards per punt return average, running one back for a touchdown. The Giants have many players who are capable of returning punts, but I consider some of the options (Antrel Rolle, Ahmad Bradshaw, Aaron Ross, Mario Manningham) too valuable for such a high risk job. It will be interesting to see if the Giants fill the return man role internally (Sinorice Moss, Tim Brown, D.J. Ware) or look outside the organization. The answer could be a player who has not yet been cut from another roster.

Entering 2010 the Giants have a lot of unanswered questions on special teams. It will be interesting to see how this unit comes together as training camp and the preseason unfold. The Giants have players capable of making their special teams surprisingly effective this coming season, but right now, I see the unit as the team’s biggest question mark, that could struggle and even cost Big Blue some games early on.

How Did The Giants Fare In The Madden 11 Ratings?

July 14th, 2010 at 7:13 PM
By Kyle Langan

While it may not be every NFL fan’s prerogative, I have been an avid player Madden games over the years. Typically the first thing I will do after getting the game is to test out how The Giants are in that particular year.

In Madden 10, The Giants were one of the strongest teams in the game. After coming off of a dominant 2008 season, The offensive live and running backs for The Giants were great, and their defense had a lot of speed which helps in Madden.

With the release of Madden 11, The Giants did not fare as well as they did in Madden 10, but none the less they were fairly strong.

Receivers and Tight Ends

12 S. Smith WR

88

89 K. Boss TE

81

88 H. Nicks WR

81

82 M. Manningham WR

76

87 D. Hixon WR

72

80 D. Hagan WR

65

47 T. Beckum TE

63

86 B. Pascoe TE

63

13 R. Barden WR

60

Kyle’s Take: At first glance these rankings seem pretty fair, but I do believe that Manningham got sold short with his 76 rating. Smith is pretty fairly rated at an 88 as well, and it was good to see Kevin Boss crack 80, though his catching should have been higher than an 82.

Running Backs

39 M. Hedgecock FB

86

27 B. Jacobs HB

84

44 A. Bradshaw HB

78

22 A. Brown HB

69

28 D. Ware HB

66

Kyle’s Take: Having Madison Hedgecock rated at an 86 is simply wrong. He should be somewhere in the 70s after his 2009 performance. I did think Bradshaw would at least be equal to Jacobs, but his rating is pretty fair. Bradshaw will be a strong player with 93 speed and 87 agility ratings. Typically unknown players like Ware and Brown will be rated below 70, though I used Brown a few times in Madden 10 and he was very solid.

Quarterbacks

10 E. Manning QB

89

5 R. Bomar QB

61

19 J. Sorgi QB

59

Kyle’s Take: Not much to say here, aside from Eli being misunderstood once again. In 2008 he was rated a 92, then fell to an 87 and this year rose to an 89. Im not seeing how he was better at any point in his career than he is now, so if he was ever a 92 he should be at least that, but I am fine with an 89. Also, is Bomar really better than Sorgi?

Offensive Line

76 C. Snee RG

96

60 S. O’Hara C

91

66 D. Diehl LT

84

67 K. McKenzie RT

82

69 R. Seubert LG

80

65 W. Beatty LT

76

79 G. Whimper RT

73

77 K. Boothe LG

70

61 A. Koets C

68

62 M. Petrus RG

64

Kyle’s Take: These are some very fair ratings. Depending on who starts and how the year goes, Beatty’s rating could rise. Snee and O’ Hara are clearly the top 2 linemen we have, so a solid job done there.

52 M. Boley LOLB

84

52 C. Sintim ROLB

71

51 Z. DeOssie ROLB

70

55 B. Kehl ROLB

67

54 J. Goff MLB

65

57 C. Blackburn LOLB

64

53 P. Dillard MLB

64

Kyle’s Take: Now I have seen it all. Zack DeOssie ranked higher than any middle linebacker on the roster. Wow. Other than that I would say the ratings are fair. I would expect Sintim’s to go up during the season. Both he and Beatty have the most potential growth in my opinion.

Kickers

9 L. Tynes K

68

6 M. Dodge P

66

Kyle’s Take: Ok, so while I never thought it possible to dislike Lawrence Tynes more than Giants 101 does, EA Sports Managed to do it. A 68 is a low blow.

Defensive Linemen

91 J. Tuck LE

92

94 M. Kiwanuka RE

83

72 O. Umenyiora RE

83

96 B. Cofield DT

81

99 C. Canty DT

77

93 J. Alford DT

76

90 J. Pierre-Paul LE

76

95 R. Bernard DT

75

97 L. Joseph DT

69

71 D. Tollefson LE

60

Kyle’s Take: Justin Tuck has been rated higher in previous Madden games but I am okay with his slight slip as he has not dominated consistently. Having Osi Umenyiora and Mathias Kiwanuka tied is a cop out, EA Sports should have picked who they thought was the better player (not that it will matter, in Madden I just start the 4 best pass rushers I have on the line anyway, Justin Tuck is usually rated over 90 at the DT spot). The rest of the line is rated fairly for now, I anticipate Canty and Pierre Paul having higher ratings though by season’s end.

Secondary

23 C. Webster CB

89

26 A. Rolle FS

83

34 D. Grant SS

80

31 A. Ross CB

78

21 K. Phillips SS

78

24 T. Thomas CB

77

25 B. Johnson CB

75

20 M. Johnson FS

73

35 C. Jones SS

66

Kyle’s Take: These ratings seem fairly arbitrary, as there is no way Webster deserves an 89 rating. And Phillips used to be a strong player, but did nothing to merit his fall to a 73. If he plays I expect his rating to rise as well. Another interesting note is how Bruce Johnson’s rating is higher than Michael Johnson’s. Terrell Thomas did indeed get sold short with a 77. He should have at least an 80.

As a team, The Giants received a pretty fair rating of 81, second in the division behind Dallas. Nothing I didn’t expect.

Madden has done an excellent job of  improving the feel of the games over the years. Some will complain that the game is too unrealistic, but I still find the game very fun to play and Madden 11 looks to have the best feel of any of them yet, as EA Sports has supposedly fixed a lot of glitches concerning defense.

I look forward to hearing everyone’s take on these ratings, Madden player or not.

Sources:

ESPN.com