News Archives

New York Giants Made the Right Move by Hiring Ben McAdoo as Offensive Coordinator

January 15th, 2014 at 7:00 AM
By Douglas Rush

In their search for a new offensive coordinator, the New York Giants and head coach Tom Coughlin had the chance to screw this up and go with more of the same. But that's not how things shook out.

With Kevin Gilbride now retired and out of the league, the team needed to pick someone to fix what co-owner John Mara had called a broken offense and with Gilbride likely to be fired if he had not stepped away, the Giants offense needed a new voice and direction to lead them next season. When Gilbride walked away, many thought Mike Sullivan would be that new voice.

But in reality, Sullivan would have been the wrong move to make, especially if they were trying to get away from the style Gilbride had been running. Sure, it worked from time to time because Gilbride called the offense for two Super Bowl winning teams, but his offense became stale and predictable to the point where it ultimately failed and thus, the change at offensive coordinator was needed. Sullivan was previously the Giants quarterbacks coach and was an assistant under Gilbride who brought the same kind of offense down with him to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers when he was hired as the offensive coordinator there and ultimately, ended up getting fired along with the rest of the Tampa coaching staff under Greg Schiano after a 4-12 season. (Plus, if we all had to sit there and watch one more shotgun draw get called on 3rd and long, furniture may have been thrown out of windows due to frustration.)

While all eyes were on Sullivan potentially being the guy to replace Gilbride and essentially, bring the same, predictable offense back to New York that fans grew to hate, a new name in Ben McAdoo entered the mix. McAdoo, who was previously the quarterbacks coach of the Green Bay Packers was someone with no affiliation with Coughlin or Gilbride whatsoever and would be bringing new ideas to an offense that was desperate for them and eventually, landed the job on Tuesday night to run the Giants offense and call the plays for the 2014 season.

The 36-year-old McAdoo is a coaching disciple of current Packers head coach Mike McCarthy, who himself was once the hot assistant coach from the San Francisco 49ers who got the Packers head coaching job because of the innovative ideas on offense; ideas on offense that eventually won a Super Bowl with the team in 2010 and is considered one of the NFL's best coaches. McAdoo will be bringing a lot of McCarthy's ideas to New York with him in 2014 and more importantly, to Eli Manning, who could use a bit of a change and rebound in 2014, especially after a season where he was sacked 39 times and intercepted 27; all unfortunate career highs.

Now Manning will get a chance to rebound with McAdoo running the offense in 2014 and the two-time Super Bowl winning quarterback will get to work with a guy that many felt was the hot coaching candidate for both an offense and to be a head coach this offseason and someone looking to make a name for himself. With the trend of the latest coaching candidates being on the offensive side of the ball, McAdoo could be the next "must have" candidate if he can take the sputtering Giants offense and make it into the explosive unit that he is promising for the 2014 season.

With the process now over and McAdoo clearly in the plans for the Giants this coming season, they can now focus on personnel moves and what player changes and additions they need to make on offense. With those moves being made, they have the right guy running the ship and got someone who will bring fresh, new ideas into the mix and hopefully, give the unit a major shot in the arm that was desperately being called for a while now.

photo credit: John M Photography via photopin cc


Tags: Ben McAdoo, Football, Green Bay Packers, Kevin Gilbride, Mike Sullivan, New York, New York Giants, NFL, Tom Coughlin

11 Responses to “New York Giants Made the Right Move by Hiring Ben McAdoo as Offensive Coordinator”

  1.  Hanshi says:

    I’m very happy that the Giants hired McAdoo. If they hadn’t been able to hire him, I would have like them to interview Joe Lombardi but I think McAdoo will be great for us.

  2.  jfunk says:

    I’m excited about this move too, but I’m not ready to declare it the correct one.

    I don’t understand everybody’s expectation that Sullivan would have had the same problems as Gilbride. Gilbride’s scheme is NOT predictable. Gilbride’s play calling is. The playbook doesn’t tell you which plays to run at what time, the guy standing there holding them makes those decisions.

    Now I don’t know enough about Sullivan to know if he would have been a good play caller, but a good play caller running Gilbride’s offense can be quite successful.

    McAdoo of course is exciting because he fixes that “not so fresh feeling” around the Giants. However, there is plenty of opportunity for this to turn into a “what where they thinking?” event 1 year from now.

    Situation and semantics aside, Eli Manning is NOT an accurate passer. Never has been. He can certainly improve with coaching if he’s not too stubborn, but short range accuracy is never going to be his strong point. It’s quite possible that a west coast scheme could blow up in our faces if Eli continually misses guys high or throws fast balls to the wrong shoulder game in and game out.

    If that comes to pass, the meme next December will be “What were they thinking bringing in a guy who’s scheme does not fit the franchise QB’s skill set?”

    I’m hoping for the best and very excited to see what comes to pass, but this is no slam dunk by any means.

    •  Krow says:

      There’s a certain organizational politics angle here that we shouldn’t miss. It looks to me like there’s an internal power struggle going on within the team’s management. Almost as if they’re trying to diminish Coughlin’s influence. This hire is surprising in that it has no link to Tom. You can’t help but think the team is looking past him … which is perfectly natural given his age and situation.

    •  rlhjr says:

      I like the hire but a week ago cautioned. Just because this guy “coached” Rodgers does not necessarily make him the second coming.

      I do however like the fresh approach. But will Coughlin like the idea of using a hybrid TE? Green Bay has no clue what a blocking TE is.
      Their offense operates at a high level utilizing hybrid tight ends.
      The Giants favor a blocker who can catch.

      Hopefully the guy is given some latitude in designing the O. And yeah like jfunk says, I hope McAdoo can improve upon Eli’s ability to throw screen and other short passes. Eli is a deep ball thrower. He does not excel at screen and slant passes designed to get a playmakers YAC. He generally gets receivers killed throwing that type of ball.

  3.  jfunk says:

    From the article:

    “Here’s what I expect,” Coughlin said. “I think the players will respond to this. We’re going to try to compromise the system with what we have here. However, there will be change. And that change will be very positive and very well-received by our team and our players. And if our players are scrambling around to learn a new system — good. That’s another fire in their rear end.”

    Doesn’t sound like a guy that’s afraid of some change.

    •  TuckThis says:

      TC is a team player. Did you expect him to pout and stamp his feet? What did you think he’d say?

    •  rlhjr says:

      Sounds like a guy who understands that change has been mandated by the owner. Hopefully defensive strategies are next on the modification block although it may take another season to force a change.

  4.  James Stoll says:

    Now go get 4 lineman a running back a TE and a WR

  5.  TuckThis says:

    Shocked but happy. Time will tell, but this is the right move. Will Eli Manning turn into Aaron Rodgers? Hardly. But I’m excited about the new possibilities for the offense.

  6.  James Stoll says:

    I’m hopeful that the change will mean we see far less than the 40 odd annual route miscommunications that price around 10 INTs and kill countless drives

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Login with: