News Archives

Tiki Barber: Inconsistency Has Prevented New York Giants QB Eli Manning from Being Great

December 27th, 2013 at 9:00 AM
By Dan Benton

Retired New York Giants running back Tiki Barber is no stranger to controversial comments on quarterback Eli Manning. In fact, some of his post-retirement statements about Easy E have stood the test of time, never to be forgotten or forgiven by the Big Blue faithful. However, with frustration boiling and much of the blame for the 2013 season being focused on Manning, the reaction to Barber's most recent comments will be interesting to see.

While appearing on WFAN on Thursday, Barber was asked about Eli, his ability and his legacy. With two Lombardi Trophies and two Super Bowl MVP awards, is Eli Manning a "great" quarterback? Barber doesn't think so.

“He’s done great things, but he doesn’t do it consistently,” Barber said. “What makes someone great in the history, in the annals of an organization or a league? It’s consistency. … That's the problem with Eli, as of late, I think, is there’s something physically off. There’s definitely a confidence issue.”

But, perhaps, the better question is: who's to blame?

It's easy to point fingers at the gunslinging quarterback, but football is a team sport and you're only as good as your supporting cast. It's for that reason, Barber says, that Manning's inconsistency should come with an asterisk.

“And that has nothing to do with him. It has everything to do with those five guys — and really it’s been eight over the course of this year — in front of him that just can’t get it done. He’s constantly throwing off his back foot. I feel like he’s pressing sometimes to make some throws and they end up sailing on him," Barber added. "It’s because of confidence and I think because he’s gotten the crap beat out of him.”

Say what you will about Eli, but there's no denying that this season has taken a physical toll on him. He's already been sacked a career-high 38 times and there's still one game remaining.

But, despite all that, Barber believes Manning can rebound and that his window for greatness is not yet closed.

“I’ve counted Eli out before and I’ve been wrong,” Barber said. “Here’s what I know about him. He has a drive, and maybe it’s a Manning thing … There’s a drive within him that sees him be able to grow and learn from things that he’s done wrong … I think it is fixable. And you talk, really, about the window for Eli. … Is it still open for him to have great success in the next three or four years? I think it is.”

It would be difficult to look at Manning's body of work and think he can't rebound after this poor season. Then again, perhaps it's just blind faith, but we feel Eli has at least one more Super Bowl victory left in him.

Photo credit: Peter McCarthy / / CC BY-ND


You're not an average fan, so why wear an average shirt to represent your team? LogoWear brings some originality to the game and will help you be the star of your team's following - not the third guy in off the bench. Your team isn't just another team. Don't be caught wearing just another shirt. Make a statement with LogoWear!

Tags: Eli Manning, Football, New York, New York Giants, NFL, Tiki Barber

One Response to “Tiki Barber: Inconsistency Has Prevented New York Giants QB Eli Manning from Being Great”

  1.  Dirt says:

    I brought up the height of Eli’s targets last night. As I tend to do, I started tangentally thinking about other things.

    Like how speaking of targets, Jernigan showed he could play in this league when given actual reps, but he was buried for years.

    So much so that earlier this year, the Giants signed Ramses Barden.

    Who was certainly tall and fit the bill in that department.

    But proved he couldn’t be relied upon.

    Remember when we were arguing whether or not he cost us the Philly game?

    Holy sh|t, that was Week 4 of last year. This bad dream has been going on for over a year.

    Forget Barden, as I told my wife at the conclusion of last week’s OT winner by Josh Brown, we make the playoffs last year if Brown is our kicker in Philly and has enough leg to reach from 51 yards. So there’s that consolation.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Login with: