News Archives

New York Giants LB Coach Jim Herrmann: All Three Linebacker Jobs are up for Grabs

August 5th, 2013 at 6:30 AM
By Douglas Rush

Before training camp started, many of the position battles that the New York Giants would encounter was well established, especially here at Giants 101. One of the biggest battles we may see all summer long is the linebacker positions; all three of them.

Currently, nine players are in camp battling it out and with each day of camp and practice that passes, along with each preseason game, this could be a battle that ends up being determined in September when the regular season kicks off on September 8.

All three starters from last season are not there; although Mathias Kiwanuka is still on the team, but has moved back to his natural position of defensive end due to the injury to Jason Pierre-Paul and the free agent departure of Osi Umenyiora to the Atlanta Falcons.

The other two starters; Chase Blackburn and Michael Boley, are no longer on the team, thus opening up what hopefully will be a fierce competition with guys seizing the jobs, and not players being handed them because nobody has emerged or earned the spot.

In camp, it's Keith Rivers, Aaron Curry, Jacquian Williams, Spencer Paysinger, Etinne Sabino and Kyle Bosworth competing for the outside linebacker spots while Mark Herzlich, Dan Connor and Jake Mussau are competing for the inside linebacker job. Over the weekend, Giants linebacker coach Jim Herrmann told Kieran Darcy of ESPN New York that there has definitely been competition with the nine players and that it will bring out the best in each of them.

"There's competitions all along the board, really," linebackers coach Jim Herrmann said prior to Saturday's practice. "And to me, that's really good. Because if they're all getting better, we're gonna be better."

Herrmann referenced that instead of set starters who play on every single down, he, along with defensive coordinator Perry Fewell, are contemplating setting certain players as first and second down linebackers and others as third down linebackers on defense, something that could really open things up for different players and allow them to grow into a certain role and excel at it.

"To me the ballgame's broken up into two phases," Herrmann said. "First and second down, and then to me third down is a completely different game, because the majority of the teams in this league are gonna throw the ball every play on third down. And so your mind-set's different, the guys you put on the field are different." 

Another potential scenario that could change things dramatically is if the Giants shift from their usual 4-3 defense into a 3-4; something that the Giants haven't used under the current coaching staff, but with certain looks closed off to the media at camp, it's been widely speculated that the team could break it out as the season gets going. If that's the case, then it's not just three jobs up for grabs, but instead four linebacker spots.

The long-shots to make the team are Bosworth, Sabino and Mussau, although if any of them impress enough, maybe one of them could be kept on for depth purposes and maybe even special teams duties on punt and kick-off duties. Most see the competition between the other six.

Both Rivers and Curry are intriguing because both were former first round picks back in the 2008 and 2009 NFL Drafts respectively, and were both brought to the Giants looking for their second chance in the NFL. With Rivers, his health is the biggest question mark and whether or not he can make it for a full 16-game schedule.

For Curry, it's the chance to show the entire NFL that he wasn't a draft bust for the Seattle Seahawks and still possesses the talent he had coming out of Wake Forest that made him the number four overall pick four years ago. What also makes Curry interesting to watch is that he could not only play outside linebacker, but he might be able to play at inside linebacker as well, which could increase his chances to get more playing time in certain schemes.

No matter who wins out at each linebacker spot this season, Herrmann really appreciates the fact that he has solid players that he can coach who are not jusy trying to beat each other out, but ones who look to help one another out on and off the field.

"It's been great competition, and the guys, the group, the room, they're all good guys," Hermann said. "There's nine good men there, and they all understand they're competing, but they're also trying to help each other get better. As a coach I can't ask anything more from them." 

With camp continuing through the week, the linebackers first real test against live competition will be this Saturday in the team's first preseason game at Heinz Field against the Pittsburgh Steelers.

Photo credit: BigBlueCowboy / Photobucket / CC BY-NC-SA


Gearing up for the fantasy season? Try weekly fantasy football games this year at DraftDay has awarded over $15 million to fantasy fans like you, so don't miss out on the newest way to play fantasy football! Create your free account and use promo code GIFT for an instant cash bonus.

Tags: Aaron Curry, Dan Connor, Football, Jacquian Williams, Keith Rivers, Mark Herzlich, New York, New York Giants, NFL, Spencer Paysinger

6 Responses to “New York Giants LB Coach Jim Herrmann: All Three Linebacker Jobs are up for Grabs”

  1.  JimStoll says:

    the one good thing about our preseason schedule is that both Pitt and the Jets ought to present teams intent on establishing a running game
    probably more than any single factor, stopping the run on first down will be the test of the LB unit (as well as the DT’s)
    if we can put teams in 2d and 8+ routinely during the season that will allow us to dictate tempo
    the last couple of years have been scary bad on this front, especially last year

  2.  fanfor55years says:

    I’ll just add that I have it from a good source that so far they live Sabino and are shocked at what he has done and cannot wait to see him in actual games. On the downside, apparently Curry has a lot if bad habits to overcome even though they see the athleticism there.

    I have been saying for months keep an eye on Paysinger. That guy was Kelly’s defensive quarterback at Oregon and is a very smart player who is an outright playmaker. If he has gained body mass (a person who attended practice told me he looks a bit bigger) he’ll have eliminated his one weakness, which has been his size, I guarantee he’ll impress. With he, Williams and Rivers we have more speed at linebacker than we’ve had as far back as I recall.

  3.  fanfor55years says:

    Should add that the reason I think the LBers are going to be a pleasant surprise are that I think most are not valuing Herzlich, Paysinger and Rivers as highly as they should. I think all three will be important players for us this season.

    •  JimStoll says:

      Rivers of course has to stay healthy
      he didn’t do that last year – not by a long shot

      I agree on Paysinger. I thought he was pushing to start last year

      Herzlich is still more enigmatic than not
      I think many of us were expecting him to push Chase aside last year, especially since Chase had been released after the 2010 season and only brought back in the late going of 2011 due to injuries
      because Herz couldn’t do that last year, I think it is fair to question just what he has left to give at this level
      did the cancer permanently take him down a notch?; or is it a 4 year recovery?

      we shall see

  4.  6string says:

    I hope they don’t fall to much in love with switching linebackers on third down. Teams like the Patriots will use the hurry up offence and we’ll be stuck with all the run stoppers in on 3rd.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Login with: